The $ignificant Blind Spot: Recruitment Agencies Lose 6/10 Customers Annually. Here’s Why.
Account Management

The $ignificant Blind Spot: Recruitment Agencies Lose 6/10 Customers Annually. Here’s Why.

Paul Sharpe
By Paul Sharpe

I am a massive fan of the role and value Account Managers can have in a recruitment agency. So much so that I recently reached out to a handful of Senior TA leaders for their views on what makes or doesn’t make a successful Account Manager. Their input and views have been incredibly insightful, and […]

I am a massive fan of the role and value Account Managers can have in a recruitment agency. So much so that I recently reached out to a handful of Senior TA leaders for their views on what makes or doesn’t make a successful Account Manager. Their input and views have been incredibly insightful, and this article includes their feedback.

If we start at the beginning and consider the purpose of an account manager:

The purpose of an Account Manager is to build and maintain strong, long-term relationships with customers. They serve as the primary liaison between the customer and the agency’s internal teams, ensuring customer satisfaction and repeat business.

It’s not about the revenue, yet this is how most Account Managers are measured and rewarded. The recruitment industry has been debating consultative selling for as long as I can remember but has it really moved on? The feedback I received suggested not, and yet this was cited as a critical factor. One TA leader said, “I really want to buy from somebody, not be sold to.” I am now dwelling on this; do we train our people on how to do this?

So how do we measure the role of the Account Manager?

As a minimum, most TA teams measure time to offer, quality of hire and cost per hire, so surely Account Managers would be equally measured on these.

Customer retention is one of the most underused business metrics in recruitment agencies and a key measure of an Account Manager’s success, along with growing market share (including cross-selling). Of course, customer satisfaction should be central to their role. As one Head of TA said, “We can tell who really puts their customers first and who is just focused on their individual targets.”

The Heads of TA I spoke to all acknowledged that building trust was paramount, but they also recognised that it wasn’t easy unless the recruiter had credibility or offered insights that informed them alongside competitor information, thought leadership, the future of work, insights into AI and tech, and talent data that helped them manage stakeholders internally. Please note that salary surveys were not mentioned once as a key differentiator. However, when asked about how their agencies innovated and developed new services, all of them had a blank expression because they don’t perceive that recruiters innovate. This is reflected in the data from the benchmark survey at NorthStar People, where we found that only 15% of agency owners and leaders have innovated with their customers in the last two years. If you want to stand out in the UK market, just innovate.

Now this isn’t easy if you aren’t consistently spending face to face time with your customer and key stakeholders, but here’s the challenge: TA professionals don’t prioritise time with recruiters for one key reason—they don’t perceive it to be the best use of their time. They rank the value of those meetings as low. This represents a massive opportunity if we can shape those meetings to be 20% looking back and 80% looking forward, with the latter focused on thought leadership. However, at present, 32% of agencies haven’t held a formal service review with their top three customers within the last two years.

Lastly, the skills of the account manager frequently came up. They all identified a good Account Manager as being worth their weight in gold but also questioned how or even if agencies invested in their development.

From our own research, when it comes to training and development, Account Managers are neglected. A massive 85% of training is spent on business development, and yet only 10% is spent on Account Management.

Why is this, and are we prioritising the wrong thing?

Research from McKinsey claims that acquiring a new customer can cost five times more than retaining an existing one. Then surely the role of the Account Manager is critical? The average recruitment agency loses six out of ten customers every year for a myriad of reasons. Failing to fix this is like trying to fill a bucket with massive holes at the bottom.

Change what you measure, change how you train Account Managers and how they are rewarded, and it may just drive customer retention.


Take Aways

The Role of a Partner, Not a Vendor
A great Account Manager goes beyond simply filling roles. They act as a consultant and a true partner by taking the time to understand a client’s business, including what’s happening within their organisation and potential future opportunities. They focus on the client’s success, knowing that this will ultimately lead to their own success and long-lasting, mutually valuable relationships.

Building Credibility and Trust
Trust is a critical element that is built over time through authenticity and honesty. Account Managers must be accountable for their work, owning both successes and failures. This also means being empowered to make decisions without needing to constantly seek approval, as this demonstrates credibility.

Market Expertise and Value
An exceptional Account Manager provides more than just candidates; they offer valuable insights into the market. They help clients by sharing information on salary price points, the availability of skills, and general market trends. This market intelligence helps the client look good within their own organisation.

Communication and Efficiency
The best Account Managers are responsive and listen for key signals from the customer. They are quick to respond and come up with solutions.

Focus on the Client’s Needs
Customers want to buy a service, not be sold one. They want a conversation where their pain points are understood and addressed. The best Account Managers are passionate about solving the customers’ problems as if they were their own.

Digital technologies alone won’t get the human customer interface right. Develop skilled, committed and engaged Account Managers and those holes in your bucket will disappear.

Paul Sharpe

Paul Sharpe

Paul Sharpe is a founding partner at NorthStar People, where he works with recruitment agency owners on operations, performance and planning. He built RPO and MSP operations from scratch at InterQuest for the likes of ASOS, IHG and Ricoh, and ran talent solutions and UK sales at Adecco before that. He is also one of a few agency recruiters who has worked in-house. Paul is now a mentor and advisor supporting recruitment agencies.