Getting more value from the recruitment technology you already own
Business Advice

Getting more value from the recruitment technology you already own

Tony Hayes
By Tony Hayes

Before you buy another piece of recruitment technology, what do you need the business to do better?

It sounds straightforward. Then the demos start, the feature lists come out, and the original business problem can get lost in the conversation.

An agency can have a CRM, automation, reporting and sourcing tools, and still leave recruiters doing work those systems were meant to make easier. Adding AI gives you more capability. You still need to know what changes in the working day.

My background spans senior technology and operational roles within recruitment businesses, followed by consulting and advisory work across the sector. I have been responsible for connecting front-office activity with back-office delivery. That experience shapes how I approach a technology problem: follow the work, understand where it breaks down, then decide what needs to change.

Find the constraint before choosing the solution

A recruiter working around the CRM might be avoiding an agreed process. Equally, the process might ask them to enter the same information twice, rely on data they cannot trust or wait for systems that do not connect properly.

You need to understand which of those problems you have. Otherwise, you can spend months encouraging adoption of something that makes the job harder, or replace a platform when the real issue sits elsewhere.

That is why I look at people, process, data and technology together. In practical terms, that means understanding who does the work, how it moves through the business, what information it relies on and how the systems support it.

Sometimes the answer is better configuration, an integration or a clearer workflow. Sometimes the platform cannot do what the business needs and replacement is justified. Work out what is getting in the way before deciding what to spend.

Five questions to locate the lost value

The five-question diagnostic gives leaders a practical place to start:

  1. Where is time being lost?
  2. Where do handoffs break down between people or teams?
  3. Where does activity become inconsistent, depending on who is doing it?
  4. Where is reporting failing to support a decision?
  5. Where are recruiters doing work that adds no commercial value?

Take one answer and follow it through. If recruiters are repeatedly checking information outside the CRM, find out why. Is the information missing, out of date, difficult to retrieve or held somewhere else? Each explanation leads to different work.

Then establish what improvement would look like. That might be less time preparing a shortlist, fewer corrections between placement and payroll, or a pipeline review that produces clear actions because the underlying information is trusted.

Make time saved count

A recruiter using AI to move faster is not the same as a recruitment business using AI to perform better.

Consider an AI tool that reduces the time spent preparing candidate submissions. The useful questions go beyond how quickly the first draft appears. How much checking is needed? Has quality held up? What happens to the time released?

If that capacity is meant to support more candidate conversations or faster client responses, build that into the workflow and review whether it happens. Compare the result with the starting point, allowing for changes in workload and market conditions. Include the cost of the tool and the work needed to run it.

Bullhorn’s 2026 GRID report found an association between AI use and reported revenue growth. That does not establish that AI caused the growth. For an agency making its own investment decisions, the useful evidence is what improves in its own operation.

Use the removal test as a starting question

If you removed the AI tools from your business tomorrow, which parts of the work would change?

That is the removal test. It helps you see where AI has become part of the work. You still need to ask what it improves. Something used occasionally can be valuable. Something everyone uses every day can still be letting them down.

Follow the answer with evidence about time, quality, consistency and commercial outcomes. The test starts the conversation. It does not replace the investigation.

Put relationship knowledge to work

The same discipline applies to the CRM. An agency can hold years of candidate and client records while recruiters still start each search from scratch.

The value depends on what those records allow someone to understand and do. Why did a candidate decline the last role? What changed in a client’s hiring plans? Who has a relationship that could help move the conversation forward?

That knowledge needs to be captured consistently, kept current and available to the people who need it. A tidy database is useful, but the commercial opportunity comes from using reliable information to make better decisions and have more relevant conversations.

As sourcing technology becomes more widely available, the relationships and knowledge an agency has built deserve serious attention. Technology can help the business retain and use them. That requires work on the data and on how people contribute to it.

Give the change an owner

Adoption follows behaviour, not the announcement.

If leaders expect the CRM to support decisions, pipeline reviews need to use it. If an automation is meant to change a handoff, the people on both sides need to understand their responsibilities. Training, usable systems and time to embed the change matter too.

Someone needs responsibility for the outcome and the authority to bring the right people together. That can sit with an existing technology, operations, finance or commercial leader. Where capacity or specialist experience is missing, outside support should strengthen the team’s ability to deliver.

In my work, that can mean resolving a defined CRM or reporting problem, establishing priorities through a diagnostic, or providing ongoing technology leadership. The starting point depends on what the business needs. The work has to carry through into implementation, adoption and a review of the result.

Before the next demo or renewal, name the commercial result you need. Establish what is preventing it, decide what should change and give someone responsibility for making it happen.

The return on your technology investment has to show up in how the business performs.

Tony Hayes leads Technology Performance at NorthStar People. He helps recruitment businesses connect technology, data and operations with commercial performance through specialist delivery, diagnostics and fractional technology leadership.

If this sounds familiar, I’m happy to talk through where the gap might be in your business.

Tony Hayes

Tony Hayes

Tony Hayes leads Technology Performance at NorthStar People. He helps recruitment businesses connect technology, data and operations with commercial performance through specialist delivery, diagnostics and fractional technology leadership.